Constructing strong relationships, both in the newsroom and with the local community, is the key to success in journalism, according to awards recipients at the New England Society of News Editors’ Journalism Awards Celebration. That kind of collaboration and gratitude for the award recognition were recurring themes in acceptance speeches as five journalists received key individual awards among a total of more than 20 honors doled out during the ceremony.
“Learn from each other and lean on one another,” said Karen Webber, recipient of the Judith Vance Weld Brown Spirit of Journalism Award. “As much as writing and reporting and photography is an individual accomplishment, putting it all together in a trusted, balanced report is a team sport, and, not to mention, it’s more fun that way.”
Webber was honored along with other journalists and college students and student newspapers at the New England Newspaper and Press Association headquarters in Dedham, Mass., Thursday, April 20, in a ceremony attended by about 70 people.
The following received the five key individual awards:
New England Journalism Educator of Year
Barbara Roche
Roche, a journalism professor at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst, was praised for her dedication to progress and innovation. She teaches courses that include Introduction to Multimedia Reporting, Entrepreneurial Journalism and Journalism Launchpad.
She has also has been a columnist at The Boston Globe, the Cape Cod Times of Hyannis, Mass., and other publications in New England.
“The fact that this (award) is coming from newspaper people just really means a lot to me,” Roche said in her acceptance speech. “There’s just no journalism like local journalism.”
Master Photographer, nondaily publication
Shannon Hicks
Hicks, a self-taught photographer, has been at The Newtown (Conn.) Bee for 28 years and is now associate editor there. The Bee’s editor, Nancy Crevier, described Hicks as discerning and particular.
“Her patience allows her to find the best — not always the first — photograph to capture a moment,” Cervier said.
Cervier also mentioned Hicks’ desire to help others in the newsroom, from interns to longtime employees.
“She is always striving to provide our paper with photos that enhance the pages, and she is always willing to share what she has learned about photography with everybody else on the staff,” Cervier said.
Master Photographer, daily publication
Mike Orazzi
Orazzi is chief photographer at The Bristol (Conn.) Press and has been with the Press for more than 20 years. Michael E. Schroeder, editor and publisher of the Press, said Orazzi has a great eye for news photography, as well as a creative eye for features.
“We, at the paper, know that when he goes out on assignment, he’s going to get the picture,” Schroeder said. “He has a wonderful relationship with the community.”
Schroeder, who accepted the award on the absent Orazzi’s behalf, said Orazzi’s work reflects the goals of the Press.
“He takes pictures that go along with our mission, which is to have a positive impact on our community,” Schroeder said.
Master Reporter
Jennette Barnes
Barnes, a reporter at The Standard-Times of New Bedford, Mass., spent time as editorial page editor there before returning to her job as a reporter. Beth Perdue, editor of the Standard-Times, said Barnes’s return to reporting stemmed from her passion for storytelling.
“She is an individual who just holds herself to a standard that is really high, particularly in today’s world of just moving so fast and getting story after story after story thrown at you,” Perdue said. “No matter what we throw at her, she is committed to telling the full story and getting the complete truth in a way that is factual while really capturing the spirit of the story, as well.”
In her acceptance speech, Barnes commended the journalism industry for its dedication to recognizing successful journalists.
“A lot of other fields don’t recognize good work the way we do,” she said. “So, even in this climate that we’re in — our business has changed so much — I really want to thank everybody for still keeping up with these awards of recognition. Not every field does that.”
Judith Vance Weld Brown Spirit of Journalism Award
Karen Webber
Webber, executive editor of the Telegram & Gazette of Worcester, Mass., received the award that honors the accomplishments of an outstanding female journalist in New England. Under her leadership, the Telegram & Gazette has won a number of honors, including New England Newspaper of the Year for the Sunday Telegram, Best Overall Website and Best Niche Publication for Worcester Living magazine, all from the New England Newspaper and Press Association.
Leah Lamson, former editor of the Telegram & Gazette, lauded Webber’s calm, capable demeanor and steady leadership, saying she is respected by her staff, her peers and the public.
In her acceptance speech, Webber pointed to women’s dedication to finding success in the newspaper industry during the past century.
“By the time I started at the T&G in 1982, things were much improved,” she said. “I was hired by a woman, and over the years, I’ve had fantastic female bosses and colleagues. I believe, for the most part, the playing field has been leveled. In fact, when I think of myself as a journalist, I don’t think of myself as a woman journalist — I think of myself as a journalist.”
She also spoke about journalism as a gratifying field, despite the many challenges of the business.
“All journalists, male and female, are challenged daily by fake news and by people who don’t have the time or the desire or the savvy to separate fact from fiction. It’s a time when many readers distrust the media, but, thankfully, for every angry email or voicemail that I get saying, ‘Shame on you,’ I also get another email saying, ‘Keep up the good work. We need you’,” she said
At the end of her speech, Webber gave advice to the college-aged journalists in the crowd.
“Keep up the hard work of journalism,” she said. “Be accurate and truthful. Verify your facts. Identify you sources. Be fair and be objective. Give context to your reporting. Be tough, but have a heart, too.”
The following other award winners were honored at the event:
College Rising Star
Amy McKeever, Stonehill College
College Top Journalist
Kelsey Bode, St. Michael’s College
New England College Newspaper of the Year
The Harvard Crimson, Harvard University
The Bowdoin Orient, Bowdoin College, first runner-up
The Free Press, Boston University, second runner-up
Castleton Spartan, Castleton University, third runner-up
The NESNEs awards
Best Opinion or Commentary Writing
Winner: John Breunig, The Advocate, Stamford, Conn., for
“A shield of words vs. rain of bullets”
Finalists:
Martha Ball, The Block Island (R.I.) Times, for “Breath of the Sea”
Marc Dion, The Herald News, Fall River, Mass., for “Jasiel the giver… of our money.”
Staff, The Providence (R.I.) Journal, for “A fraud, a farce, a dog-and-pony show”
Ron Chimelis, The Republican, Springfield, Mass., for “Put yourself in Granby cop’s shoes”
Best Hard News/General Reporting Story
Winner: Mackenzie Rigg, The News-Times, Danbury, Conn., for
“A Connecticut Doctor in Africa”
Finalists:
Staff, Taunton (Mass.) Daily Gazette, for “Search for Answers”
Josh Kovner, The Hartford (Conn.) Courant, for “Left in Limbo”
Staff, Republican-American, Waterbury, Conn., for “District voting gets tested”
Stephanie Barry, The Republican, Springfield, Mass., for “Inside the Mob”
Best Feature Story
Winner: Robert Kiener, Stowe (Vt.) Guide & Magazine, for “Bill Lee”
Finalists:
Steve Barlow, Republican-American, Waterbury, Conn., for “The Flood of 1955”
Mark Davis, Seven Days, Burlington, Vt., for “Right in Rutland”
Lisa Spear, The Recorder, Greenfield, Mass., for “Final lullaby”
Cyndi Wood, The Ellsworth (Maine) American., for “Alex Robbins, age 3, loses his battle with heart disease”
Best Enterprise/Long-Form Reporting Story
Winner: Staff, Cape Cod Times, Hyannis, Mass., for
“Special Report: Climate Change Hits Home”
Finalists:
Alex Elvin, Vineyard Gazette, Martha’s Vineyard, Mass., for “Coastal Ponds Balancing People and the Environment”
Jeannette Hinkle, Ipswich (Mass.) Chronicle, for “The green crab threat”
Tom Relihan, The Recorder, Greenfield, Mass., for “Charter Schools Day 1”
Izaskun Larraneta, Lisa McGinley and Tess Townsend, The Day, New London, Conn., for “I-95 Deadly, Overcrowded”
Best Watchdog or Neighborhood Reporting Story
Winner: Patrick Ronan and Hongyi Gong, The Patriot Ledger, Quincy, Mass., for
“Culture Shift in Quincy”
Finalists:
Lindsay Tice, Sun Journal, Lewiston, Maine, for “New Attitude”
K.C. Myers, Cape Cod Times, Hyannis, Mass., for “Path to Recovery”
Matthew Kauffman and Jenna Carlesso. The Hartford (Conn.) Courant, for “Hartford Soccer Stadium”
Douglas Moser, The Eagle-Tribune, North Andover, Mass., for “Is This Full Time?”
Best News Photo
Winner: Jack Foley, The Herald News, Fall River, Mass., for “Ledge”
Finalists:
Glenn Russell, The Burlington (Vt.) Free Press, for “Speed dating with Trump and Sanders”
Steven King, Worcester (Mass.) Magazine, “Comfort”
Steven King, Tom Matthews and Erika Sidor, Worcester (Mass.) Magazine, for
“Officer Ronald Tarentino Jr., End of Shift: May 22, 2017”
Robin Chan, The Hingham (Mass.) Journal, for “Unidentified girl holds a candle in memory of Cpl. Orlando”
Best Sports / Feature Photo
Winner: Robin Chan, Scituate (Mass.) Mariner, for
“Steven Litchfield checks the time of the tower”
Finalists:
Robin Chan, Marshfield (Mass.) Mariner, for “It’s a bird, it’s a plane, it’s Maria!”
Peter Pereira, The Standard-Times, New Bedford, Mass., for “Forbidden Seas”
John Love, Sentinel & Enterprise, Fitchburg, Mass., for “Fitchburg State men’s soccer players attack their opponent’s net”
Trent Campbell, Addison County Independent, Middlebury, Vt., for
“Brooke Tupper throws herself into the girls’ 16-year-old arm wrestling competition”
Best Video
Winner: Adam Silverman and Philip Tortora, The Burlington (Vt.) Free Press, for
“The Shooting of Phil Grenon”
Finalists:
Robin Chan, The Hingham (Mass.) Journal, for “Blossoming into One’s Own”
Peter Huoppi, The Day, New London, Conn., for “Bob Crelin wants you to see the stars”
Eva Sollberger, Seven Days, Burlington, Vt., for “Stuck In Vermont: Trumpnado Hits Burlington”
Ryan Mercer, The Burlington (Vt.) Free Press, for “Volunteers run their own race at Vermont City Marathon”
Best Digital Innovation
Winner: Staff, Cape Cod Times, Hyannis, Mass., for
“Life on the Edge: How Climate Change Affects Cape Cod”
Finalists:
Peter Huoppi, Casey O’Neill, Keith O’Brien and Mike DiMauro, The Day, New London, Conn., for “Casey and The Sports Doctor”
Staff, Vineyard Gazette, Martha’s Vineyard, Mass., for “Bakers experiment with ancient grains”
Best in Sports
Winner: Joel M. Lehman, St. Albans (Vt.) Messenger, for “Flight and Family”
Finalists:
Matthew Kauffman and Tom Yantz, The Hartford (Conn.) Courant, for “Inquiry Alleges Coach Cheated”
Taylor Vortherms, The Ellsworth (Maine) American, for
“Invisible, incapacitating concussions are sidelining high school athletes”
Who brings us the news? Men, mostly
Gene Policinski, inside the First Amendment
Gene Policinski is chief operating officer of the Newseum Institute and senior vice president of the Institute’s First Amendment Center. He can be reached at gpolicinski@newseum.org.
Follow him on Twitter:
@genefac
Who brings us the news? Mostly it’s still men, according to a new Women’s Media Center study, “Divided 2017.”
The report says that’s so among the major TV networks, online versions of CNN, Fox, The Huffington Post and The Daily Beast, and the nation’s 10 largest newspapers:
• Male anchors and reporters predominate by about 3 to 1 among broadcast news outlets, which the center notes is a “regression” from how things used to be. Work by women anchors, field reporters and correspondents actually declined, falling to 25.2 percent of reports in 2016 from 32 percent when the Women’s Media Center published its 2015 “Divided” report.
• For newspapers and wire services such as The Associated Press and Reuters, “bylines” run about 62 percent male. Online, men receive 53.9 percent of bylines.
• The Women’s Media Center reports that “men produce the most stories on sports, weather, and crime and justice. Women’s bylines are largely on lifestyle, health and education news.”
The gender disparity shown in the Women’s Media Center survey is obvious in terms of numbers and simple equity, considering that women make up 51 percent of the population. But its implications, including the impact on news credibility, might not be so clear to news consumers.
Cristal Williams Chancellor, the Women’s Media Center’s director of communications, noted in an interview that many of our fellow citizens are “comfortable” with men in anchor chairs or dominating story bylines. But in an era in which a majority of people say they distrust the news media and its motives, the most credible news operations should have diverse staffs that represent both their subjects and their audiences, she said.
Clearly, the news industry still falls short of having enough women to meet that goal.
Why?
It’s not for a lack of qualified female job candidates-in-training: Women made up two-thirds of students enrolled in journalism and media-oriented degree programs during the fall 2013 semester, according to the most recent Annual Survey of Journalism and Mass Communication Enrollment.
One factor in the lack of overall visibility might come from the finding that “lifestyle, health and education” remain the topics where women most likely appear. I can recall that same circumstance in newsrooms of the 1960s.
Another bit of history: The American Society of News Editors’ annual newsroom census found in 2016 that the number of women leaders and employees has remained nearly the same since the 1990s. The survey that year reported that “women made up about a third of newsroom employees overall, with a higher number employed at online-only sites than at newspapers. Women comprised 38 percent of daily newspaper employees in this year’s survey and nearly 50 percent of online-only news organization employees.”
At a 2014 ASNE conference, women who were editors also called for changes in hiring and the review/promotion process to address old canards of how women in leadership roles are perceived. Kathleen Davis, Fast Company’s senior editor, referenced a study of 248 performance reviews of 180 men and women in media, prepared by both men and women, which showed the word “abrasive” was used 17 times for women and never for men.
None of these stats or biases is the sole province of newsrooms, to be sure. And going back to the mid-20th century, women in leadership roles in major news operations — from the news desk to the corporate suite — more often resulted from inherited ownership than from corporate diversity considerations.
But the profession that represents us all in gathering and reporting the news ought to be more of a leader in the 21st century in being representative of all of us.